Current New Middletown median home price: $218,711
| Date | Average price (≈) | Minimum price (⇓) | Maximum price (⇑) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 January | $247,578 | $222,820 | $272,336 |
| 2026 February | $249,165 | $224,248 | $274,081 |
| 2026 March | $250,762 | $225,686 | $275,838 |
| 2026 April | $252,369 | $227,132 | $277,606 |
| 2026 May | $253,986 | $228,587 | $279,385 |
| 2026 June | $255,614 | $230,052 | $281,175 |
| 2026 July | $257,252 | $231,527 | $282,977 |
| 2026 August | $257,604 | $231,844 | $283,365 |
| 2026 September | $258,110 | $232,299 | $283,921 |
| 2026 October | $258,814 | $232,933 | $284,695 |
| 2026 November | $259,180 | $233,262 | $285,098 |
| 2026 December | $260,841 | $234,757 | $286,925 |