Current Fire Island Pines median home price: $1,188,712
| Date | Average price (≈) | Minimum price (⇓) | Maximum price (⇑) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 September | $1,185,966 | $1,067,370 | $1,304,563 |
| 2025 October | $1,184,606 | $1,066,146 | $1,303,067 |
| 2025 November | $1,187,839 | $1,069,055 | $1,306,623 |
| 2025 December | $1,191,585 | $1,072,426 | $1,310,743 |