Current New Carlisle median home price: $227,967
| Date | Average price (≈) | Minimum price (⇓) | Maximum price (⇑) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 September | $250,199 | $225,179 | $275,218 |
| 2025 October | $251,914 | $226,722 | $277,105 |
| 2025 November | $253,641 | $228,276 | $279,005 |
| 2025 December | $255,379 | $229,841 | $280,917 |