Current New Carlisle median home price: $227,967
| Date | Average price (≈) | Minimum price (⇓) | Maximum price (⇑) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 January | $257,130 | $231,417 | $282,843 |
| 2026 February | $258,893 | $233,003 | $284,782 |
| 2026 March | $260,667 | $234,601 | $286,734 |
| 2026 April | $262,454 | $236,209 | $288,700 |
| 2026 May | $264,253 | $237,828 | $290,679 |
| 2026 June | $266,065 | $239,458 | $292,671 |
| 2026 July | $266,809 | $240,129 | $293,490 |
| 2026 August | $265,904 | $239,314 | $292,494 |
| 2026 September | $265,207 | $238,686 | $291,727 |
| 2026 October | $265,798 | $239,218 | $292,378 |
| 2026 November | $266,859 | $240,174 | $293,545 |
| 2026 December | $268,689 | $241,820 | $295,558 |